Climaticus markClimaticus Homepage
A globe formed from rows of crosses and circles against a dark background.
Climaticus markThe Climaticus Brief

The Climaticus Brief

Issue · 6 November 2026

By Katherine Casey, Climaticus

Authored by
Katherine Casey
Published by
Climaticus
Published

Week ending 6 November 2026  |  Energy, research and regulatory intelligence from Climaticus  |  Governance
Information cut-off: 5 November 2026. Events after that date have not been checked.

Summary

This issue asks how three connection arrangements allocate the costs, capacity constraints and risks of moving biomethane onto a gas network between producers, network operators and consumers. The new reporting is a 3 November trade report that Gasunie Transport Services has repurposed a 60 km pipeline to gather biomethane in the Netherlands[1]; the Irish connection policy (announced 15 June 2026) and the Northern Ireland consultation (opened October 2026) are older context[2][3].

Also covered: a Commission proposal on liquid digestates, the status of biochar certification, a planning submission deadline in Gort and a modelling study of digestion with thermochemical treatment of digestate.

Gathering biomethane: who bears the connection cost?

The three approaches differ in maturity: a reported physical conversion, an adopted regulatory policy and a consultation proposal. The table shows what each source says about cost and risk, and what it leaves open.

Three approaches to biomethane connection, with the evidence status of each
ApproachStatusWhat the sources stateWhat remains open
Netherlands: repurposed gathering pipelineConversion reported 3 November 2026; Gasunie's 2024 page planned service from late 2025; operation not confirmed.About 60 km collecting gas from the RENDO, Enexis and Coteq networks, with two new boosters at Ommen[1]. Gas is produced at about 8 bar and the national network runs at 66 bar, bridged at one compressor site[4].Cost, capacity, start date and who funds the line or compression.
Ireland: Commission for Regulation of Utilities (CRU) connection policyAdopted policy; decision paper CRU/202655 dated 12 June 2026, announced 15 June[5][2].The CRU decision paper extends the economic test appraisal period from 10 to 15 years, keeps a 30% standard customer contribution, and allocates 30% of the cost of the centralised grid injection (CGI) facility to connecting parties pro rata to contracted capacity, with Mitchelstown at 175 GWh a year in phase one and 700 GWh a year at full operation[5].Who funds the balance of a CGI facility, and the timing of a developers' choice model (left to the CRU's 2027 Workplan).
Northern Ireland: hub and spoke proposalConsultation proposal, closing 5.00 pm on 15 December 2026[3].A secondary report describes smaller sites feeding a central facility, strategic reinforcement costs spread across gas consumers subject to caps, producers paying for direct connections, and an indicative £13 million a year for 2028 to 2035 as a preferred option subject to a business case[6].Final policy and funding decisions, which depend on the consultation outcome.

Why does it matter? A gathering line, compression, a direct connection, a centralised injection facility and strategic reinforcement are different cost items, and each approach places them differently. Only the Irish and Northern Ireland sources describe allocation, and only in part.

Who needs to act, and what should they check? Producers choosing a site can check the distance to the nearest injection point, how contracted capacity is set and how the contribution and financial security are calculated. Respondents to the Northern Ireland consultation have until 15 December to test the cost-sharing proposal against the full text.

Interpretation: The Dutch description concerns engineering and cannot serve as evidence for any allocation of cost. The Irish policy gives connecting parties a stated share of a centralised facility in proportion to contracted capacity, which would make the method for setting that capacity an important term for each producer. The Northern Ireland proposal would widen the group paying for strategic reinforcement to all gas consumers, subject to caps, so respondents outside the gas sector may have reason to engage.

Evidence note: the Dutch conversion rests on one trade report and the Northern Ireland strategy detail on a consultancy summary, and each should be read as attributed reporting until the primary texts are confirmed; the Irish figures are taken from the CRU decision paper (see the source notes).

Policy and regulation

Renewable Heat Obligation: Bill publication and commencement are separate milestones

Mondaq reported on 13 May 2026 that commencement is now expected in 2027, that the Bill was notified to the European Commission on 23 December 2025 and that the standstill ran to 29 June 2026, with commencement and obligation period dates unfixed[7]. Legal 500 listed the Bill as priority legislation on 1 October 2026 without giving a date[8]. Earlier issues carried a Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment target of publishing the Bill in late 2026, which this issue did not re-verify. Publication in late 2026 and commencement in 2027 are compatible, so the open question is the interval between them. No Bill text was located this week, which does not establish that none exists.

Energy market

United Kingdom: Green Gas Support Scheme cap (context from 28 and 29 October)

The Anaerobic Digestion and Bioresources Association (ADBA) stated on 29 October that the Budget of 28 October left the scheme cap frozen, that the freeze has lasted more than four months and could continue until the 2027 spending review, and that more than a dozen shovel-ready plants await approval; these are ADBA assertions relayed by a trade outlet, and the 2026 to 2027 application budget cap was £124.9 million[9].

Interpretation: A long freeze creates a risk that approvals, grid connection offers and financing arrangements fall out of step, because each runs to its own timetable. The report does not identify which projects face expiring deadlines, so the scale of that risk is unknown.

Agriculture, digestate and biochar

Commission proposes extending RENURE to liquid digestates

The European Commission's news item of 19 October 2026 states that it has opened a public consultation on a draft targeted amendment to the Nitrates Directive to "facilitate the use of certain liquid digestates as an alternative to chemical fertilisers while ensuring that environmental risks are managed"; the next steps are a one-month feedback period, endorsement by the Nitrates Committee, a three-month scrutiny period for Parliament and Council, and formal adoption[12].

Existing rules. The Directive limits livestock manure, including processed manure, to 170 kg of nitrogen per hectare per year, and the RENURE rules in Commission Directive (EU) 2026/288 let Member States exempt certain manure-recovered nitrogen materials that resemble chemical fertilisers, currently ammonium salts, mineral concentrates and struvite; those rules bind Member States only if they choose to implement them, with transposition by 2 March 2028 at the latest[12][13].

What the draft states. The draft Directive circulated on 16 October 2026, which carries a statement that it is not adopted or endorsed, would add a fourth type of material to the RENURE list: a liquid digestate separated by decanter centrifuge from agricultural, agro-food or separately collected biowaste feedstocks, with digestates containing mixed municipal waste or sewage, industrial or dredging sludge excluded in the recitals[14]. Member States would apply an equivalence coefficient of 1, always take ammonia precautions for these digestates, protect Natura 2000 areas and drinking water catchments, address contaminants where appropriate, and set phosphorus rules for farms using the option, and they could choose not to implement the amendments[14].

What remains unverified. The Annex does not restate the quality criteria in the other points of the existing text, so a digestate would appear to need to meet those as well, but this brief has not tested that reading and does not conclude that any digestate would qualify. The Commission's Have Your Say page gives a feedback period of 16 October to 13 November 2026, closing at midnight Brussels time, with Commission adoption planned for the second quarter of 2027[15].

Interpretation: The draft would give Member States an option and not an exemption, so any benefit to Irish digestion operators would depend on the final text, on national implementation and on whether a given digestate met the conditions, and operators should not assume eligibility.

Biochar: the framework, the methodology and one draft scheme standard

Biochar carbon removal falls within the EU Carbon Removals and Carbon Farming Regulation, and the Commission's certification page lists Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/285 as covering permanent removals including biochar, without stating application dates[16]. Voluntary schemes may set their own rules within that framework. The one draft this brief reviewed, Carbon Standards' EU biochar standard, requires European Biochar Certificate certification of the biochar, imposes feedstock limits and tracks material to the soil application site[17]. Whether those requirements come from the delegated methodology or from the scheme was not verified, so they should not be read as applying to every route. The draft's consultation closed on 24 September 2026 and the final standard is unverified.

Interpretation: Nitrogen-recovery rules under the Nitrates Directive and carbon-removal certification are separate regimes that assess different things. The existence of a methodology does not establish that digestate-derived biochar is an eligible feedstock in Ireland, that certification would be granted, or that credits could be issued or sold. The Spotlight study credits fertiliser and fossil energy displacement, and this brief did not establish whether it also credits carbon storage in biochar.

Planning and social licence

Gort biogas appeal: further-information submission window

The Clare Champion reported on 2 November that Sustainable Bio-Energy Limited proposes an industrial-scale biogas facility in Gort, County Galway, that An Bord Pleanála, now An Coimisiún Pleanála, conceded a High Court challenge by the Gort Biogas Concern Group in November 2023, that the Commission requested further information in March 2026 and directed new site and newspaper notices by 21 October 2026, and that submissions are due by 19 November 2026[18]; Galway Bay FM, on 21 October 2026, independently reports the same date, that submissions go to An Coimisiún Pleanála, and that a new site notice has been posted[19]. The Commission's case page records case PL07.320207, planning authority reference 191812, lodged and reactivated on 19 July 2024 (formerly 308942), with the applicant as first party appellant, and shows no submission deadline, further-information notice or decision[20]. Galway County Council's ePlanning record for reference 191812 shows an application received in 2019, refused on 2 December 2020 and appealed (ABP-308942-20), with no further information recorded[21]. The reported submission deadline is 19 November 2026, given by both outlets and by a photograph of the site notice found online, which states that it was erected on 15 October 2026 and allows five weeks for submissions[22]. The notice describes further information, including an updated Environmental Impact Assessment Report and an updated Natura Impact Statement, received on 26 August 2026 for a reopened appeal on the 2019 application (reference 191812, appeal ABP-320207-24), and not a fresh application as the press description suggests[22]. The Commission case page did not show the date or the notice.

Research from other countries describes how local engagement relates to project outcomes, and it does not support an inference about Gort. A study of 91 French anaerobic digestion projects, based on 49 interviews and 455 regional press articles, found that trust between project leaders and local people, and early dialogue, were associated with whether projects went ahead[23]; a Danish case study of the Solrød plant identified 30 non-technological success factors and reports that local questions commonly concern odour, heavy transport and property values[24]. These findings come from France and Denmark, this brief has not found comparable peer-reviewed evidence for Ireland, and nothing in them indicates how the Gort application will proceed. Public scrutiny, disagreement and accountability form part of the planning process in their own right, and early dialogue is better read as a way of informing decisions than as a route to securing acceptance.

Civitas by Climaticus is a structured community engagement methodology for anaerobic digestion projects that emphasises transparency and early dialogue with local people, and it is designed to support the engagement conditions described in these studies (see the disclosure note at the end of this issue, which applies to this reference).

The appeal for a bio-renewables facility at Killough Quarry, Holycross, County Tipperary (case PL92.500924), was lodged on 5 March 2026 by Roadstone Limited, with the Killough Community Group as third-party appellant, and the Commission's case page showed no decision when accessed on 5 November[25].

Scholarly Spotlight: modelled digestion of Irish slurry and silage with thermochemical treatment of digestate

The research

The authors built a computer model of six ways of treating one tonne of Irish cattle slurry and grass silage and compared their environmental effects. The six ways are listed below, where pyrolysis means heating without oxygen, which produces biochar, and hydrothermal carbonisation, or HTC, means treating wet material under heat and pressure, which produces a solid fuel called hydrochar.

  1. Digestion alone: the biogas turned into electricity (S1 in the paper).
  2. Digestion alone: the biogas upgraded to biomethane for the gas grid (S2).
  3. Digestion followed by pyrolysis: the biogas turned into electricity (S3).
  4. Digestion followed by HTC: the biogas turned into electricity (S4).
  5. Digestion followed by pyrolysis: the biogas upgraded to biomethane (S5).
  6. Digestion followed by HTC: the biogas upgraded to biomethane (S6).

The finding

Mediboyina, Talwar and Murphy (20 January 2026) used a consequential life cycle assessment, which counts the fossil energy and mineral fertiliser that each route's products displace elsewhere, to compare the six routes per tonne of a 0.4 to 0.6 mix of cattle slurry and grass silage[26]. Five of the six showed a net climate saving, and the exception was digestion for electricity alone (S1), which showed a small net climate burden that the authors attribute mainly to the mineral fertiliser needed for grassland intensification, accounting for more than half of its incurred emissions[26]. Digestion with HTC for electricity (S4) performed best, followed by digestion with HTC for biomethane (S6)[26].

The ranking follows from what each route is credited with displacing. In the electricity routes (S3 and S4) the dominant saving is fossil electricity, with coal assumed as the short-term marginal fuel, and in the biomethane routes (S2, S5 and S6) it is natural gas and other fossil fuels; the HTC routes lead the pyrolysis routes (S3 and S5) through higher energy recovery and greater substitution of mineral fertiliser, by way of the hydrochar and the treated process water[26]. The four routes with a second treatment step also reduced terrestrial acidification and freshwater eutrophication relative to digestion alone, and fossil depletion savings reached up to 99% against the fossil reference[26].

The limitation

Three assumptions materially influence the ranking: the coal credit for displaced electricity in S1, S3 and S4 increases the credit given to the electricity routes; the HTC inventory derives from a pilot-scale plant at Ingelia in Spain; and HTC process water is assumed to be treated by reverse osmosis and applied to grassland, which the authors describe as emerging practice and which is unresolved at scale[26]. The assessment is a model without measurements from an operating Irish plant, it uses deterministic sensitivity checks only and names a full uncertainty analysis as future work, and it contains no cost assessment although the authors acknowledge that pyrolysis and HTC add capital and operating costs[26]. The result therefore applies to this feedstock mix, boundary and set of assumptions, and it does not establish commercial viability or that any one route is superior in general.

The implication

This is Climaticus's reading and not a finding of the authors: readers evaluating a climate claim for a digestion project should check which fuel the displaced energy is assumed to be, how the fertiliser pathway is treated and where the system boundary is drawn, because the sign of the S1 result depended on the fertiliser pathway.

Mediboyina, M.K., Talwar, N. and Murphy, F. (2026) Consequential life cycle assessment of integrated anaerobic digestion–pyrolysis–HTC systems for bioenergy and biofertiliser from cattle slurry and grass silage. Sustainability, 18(2), 1040. DOI: 10.3390/su18021040. Open access (Creative Commons Attribution). Title, authors, DOI and date checked against the publisher's page; this brief read most but not all of the full text and did not review supplementary material.

Consultations, funding and deadlines

Open consultations and requests for evidence

Open consultations, requests for evidence and submission windows at 5 November 2026
ItemJurisdictionDeadlineAudience and actionVerification caveat
Biomethane strategy and policy framework consultationNorthern Ireland5.00 pm, 15 December 2026Producers, gas consumers, farming and water bodies: respond to the Department for the Economy.Deadline confirmed on the Department page; content from a secondary report[3][6].
Biomethane business case request for informationNorthern Ireland5.00 pm, 19 November 2026Biomethane producers and businesses interested in using biomethane, each answering the set of questions that applies to them.Department page confirms the deadline. The business case for a possible 2028 to 2035 scheme is still in development and needs approvals, and responding does not guarantee funding or a place in any future scheme[27].
Liquid digestates amendment to the Nitrates DirectiveEUMidnight Brussels time, 13 November 2026Farmers, digestion operators, water bodies: respond through the Commission's feedback portal.Deadline confirmed on the Commission's Have Your Say page, which also shows the draft Directive and Annex; registration or login is needed to give feedback[15].
Gort biogas appeal: further-information submissionsIreland (County Galway)19 November 2026 (reported)Residents and other interested parties: submissions to An Coimisiún Pleanála.The deadline is reported by two local news outlets and a photographed site notice but was not shown on the Commission case page. Anyone making a submission should check the current notice and submission requirements with An Coimisiún Pleanála[22][18][19][20].

Open funding opportunities

This brief verified no open funding window this week.

Closed windows and forthcoming rounds being monitored

Closed windows and forthcoming rounds
ItemJurisdictionStatusCaveat
Biomethane Capital Grant Scheme, second round (up to €200 million)IrelandExpression of interest closed at 5.00 pm on 30 October 2026; the Department intends to start the formal process "in the following weeks"; no date retrieved. An expression of interest is not required to apply and is not an offer of funding[28].Page is the Department's own; the formal round date is unknown.
Green Gas Support Scheme capUnited KingdomCap reported frozen by ADBA; no date for release[9].Trade association assertion.

The Standing Watch

Status terms: Confirmed unchanged (this week's source matches the position in the 30 October issue), No update verified (not checked or not retrievable, which does not mean nothing has happened), Closing date unverified, New entry and Closed.

Standing Watch at 5 November 2026
IssuePosition at cut-offStatus
EU Methane Regulation importer deadlinesThe 30 October issue reported a Council attempt to agree a position scheduled for 6 November; the Council position at the cut-off is not verified.No update verified
Renewable Heat ObligationPriority legislation; commencement expected in 2027 (Mondaq, May); no Bill text located this week[7][8].No update verified
Second-round AD capital grantsExpression of interest closed 30 October; formal round awaited[28].Closed (expression of interest)
EU liquid digestates and RENUREProposal published 19 October; feedback period 16 October to 13 November confirmed on the Have Your Say page; adoption planned for the second quarter of 2027; existing RENURE conditions read in Directive (EU) 2026/288; draft Directive and Annex read; change since the 30 October issue not assessed[12][15][13][14].Closing date confirmed
Biochar under the EU carbon removals frameworkDelegated Regulation (EU) 2026/285 listed; application date not stated[16].New entry
Gort biogas applicationFurther information received 26 August 2026 on a reopened appeal; 19 November submission deadline reported by two local outlets and a photographed site notice; not shown on the Commission case page[22][18][19][20].New entry
Killough appeal (PL92.500924)Case page shows no decision when accessed 5 November[25].Confirmed unchanged
Northern Ireland biomethane strategyDepartment page confirms closing at 5.00 pm on 15 December; the business case request for information closes at 5.00 pm on 19 November[3][27].Confirmed unchanged
Ireland's Climate Action Plan; CBAM downstream extension; EU ETS review; national AD planning guidance; United Kingdom Green Gas Support Scheme capCarried from the 30 October issue; nothing new was retrieved or checked this week, other than the ADBA statement of 29 October on the cap[9].No update verified

Where this lands

  1. Operators and advisers can separate the established nitrogen-recovery requirements in Directive (EU) 2026/288, which place duties on Member States, from any assumption about the proposed liquid-digestate category, whose draft adds decanter-centrifuge liquid digestates from agricultural, agro-food or separately collected biowaste feedstocks, with duties on Member States for application, vulnerable areas and phosphorus[13][14].
  2. A developer responding to a request for further information can publish the response in an accessible form, with a plain-language summary of the points it answers, so that the public can scrutinise it within the submission window[18].
  3. A party whose contract depends on the Renewable Heat Obligation can list the assumptions it makes about commencement, eligibility and certificate treatment and obtain appropriate advice before relying on them, since the sources reviewed fix neither commencement nor obligation period dates and this brief did not establish eligibility or certificate treatment[7].

Climaticus relevance and disclosure

Climaticus operates The Biogenia Marketplace, a verified marketplace for biomethane and biogenic carbon dioxide, and Civitas by Climaticus, a structured community engagement methodology. The Biogenia Marketplace is relevant to the sale of biomethane, which follows network connection; Civitas is relevant to the planning section as a method of community engagement. References to Climaticus products do not imply involvement in, endorsement of, or a commercial relationship with any project or application discussed.

Sources

  1. Bioenergy Insight, Gasunie subsidiary GTS repurposes 60km natural gas pipeline for biomethane transport, 3 November 2026, trade report: bioenergy-news.com ↑ text
  2. Commission for Regulation of Utilities, New CRU decision supports biomethane development in Ireland, 15 June 2026 (announcement; the full decision, linked from this page, could not be retrieved): cru.ie ↑ text
  3. Department for the Economy (Northern Ireland), Biomethane Strategy and Policy Framework consultation, closing 5.00 pm on 15 December 2026 (only the closing date was retrieved): economy-ni.gov.uk ↑ text
  4. Gasunie, Gathering pipeline provides more biomethane in the Dutch network, 1 February 2024 (planned service from late 2025; does not confirm operation): gasunie.nl ↑ text
  5. Commission for Regulation of Utilities, Biomethane Connections Policy: Decision Paper, CRU/202655, published 12 June 2026 (PDF supplied to the editor) ↑ text
  6. Planning Geek, NI biomethane strategy consultation seeks farm views, 24 October 2026, secondary report: planninggeek.co.uk ↑ text
  7. Mondaq, Ireland's Renewable Heat Obligation, 13 May 2026: mondaq.com ↑ text
  8. Legal 500, Government legislative priorities for autumn 2026, 1 October 2026: legal500.com ↑ text
  9. Bioenergy Insight, ADBA warns Budget ‘leaves biomethane behind’, 29 October 2026, trade report of ADBA statements: bioenergy-news.com ↑ text
  10. Bioenergy Insight, Future Biogas takes full ownership of six AD plants in £104m deal, 26 October 2026, trade report: bioenergy-news.com ↑ text
  11. Bioenergy Insight, Cycle0 begins biomethane injection at converted Italian biogas plant, 27 October 2026, trade report: bioenergy-news.com ↑ text
  12. European Commission (DG Environment), Commission proposes more flexibility for liquid digestates, news item of 19 October 2026, the primary source for the proposal; it states no feedback closing date: environment.ec.europa.eu ↑ text
  13. Commission Directive (EU) 2026/288 of 9 February 2026 amending Council Directive 91/676/EEC as regards the use of certain fertilising materials from livestock manure, Official Journal, 10 February 2026 (recitals, Articles 1 to 4 and the Annex read from the Official Journal text supplied to the editor): eur-lex.europa.eu ↑ text
  14. European Commission, draft Commission Directive amending Council Directive 91/676/EEC as regards the use of certain types of digestate derived from livestock manure, Ref. Ares(2026)9771357, 16 October 2026 (draft not adopted or endorsed; Directive text and Annex) ↑ text
  15. European Commission, Have Your Say: Nitrates, extending the rules on recovered nitrogen from manure (initiative 19475), page text supplied to the editor on 5 November 2026: ec.europa.eu ↑ text
  16. European Commission, Certification methodologies under the Carbon Removals and Carbon Farming Regulation (page states last update 10 June 2026 and contains an internal date inconsistency on the carbon farming act): climate.ec.europa.eu ↑ text
  17. Carbon Standards, EU Biochar Carbon Removal Standard, published 27 July 2026, modified 8 October 2026 (draft standard; the page's 30-day description does not match its stated dates): carbon-standards.com ↑ text
  18. Clare Champion, Public meeting tonight as biogas threat back in Gort, 2 November 2026: clarechampion.ie ↑ text
  19. Galway Bay FM, Public submissions open on proposed Gort Biogas facility, 21 October 2026, local news report: galwaybayfm.ie ↑ text
  20. An Coimisiún Pleanála, Case PL07.320207 (planning authority reference 191812; lodged and reactivated 19 July 2024, formerly 308942), read 5 November 2026; no submission deadline shown: pleanala.ie ↑ text
  21. Galway County Council ePlanning, application reference 191812, record generated 5 November 2026: eplanning.ie ↑ text
  22. Site notice of further information, Application reference 191812 and appeal ABP-320207-24, erected 15 October 2026 at the request of An Coimisiún Pleanála; photograph found online by the editor; no official posting of the notice was located and the origin of the photograph is unverified ↑ text
  23. Bourdin, S. and Josset, C. (2020) On the (un)successful deployment of renewable energies: territorial context matters, Energy Studies Review, 24(1): doi.org ↑ text
  24. Nielsen, M.B. and Kjær, T. (2022) Successfully navigating the project lifecycle for deployment of centralized biogas projects: the case of Solrød Biogas, Energies, 15(16), 5879: doi.org ↑ text
  25. An Coimisiún Pleanála, Case PL92.500924 (Killough Quarry, Holycross, County Tipperary), accessed 5 November 2026: pleanala.ie ↑ text
  26. Mediboyina, M.K., Talwar, N. and Murphy, F. (2026) Consequential life cycle assessment of integrated anaerobic digestion–pyrolysis–HTC systems for bioenergy and biofertiliser from cattle slurry and grass silage, Sustainability, 18(2), 1040, publisher page: mdpi.com; DOI: doi.org ↑ text
  27. Department for the Economy (Northern Ireland), Biomethane Business Case Request for Information, closing 5.00 pm on 19 November 2026: economy-ni.gov.uk ↑ text
  28. Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment, Biomethane Capital Grant Scheme: Expression of Interest (EOI), October 2026: gov.ie ↑ text
Climaticus mark

Keeping up with Climaticus

Sign up to receive a monthly newsletter with the most important news and research from the briefings and beyond.

Your email will be used only to send the Climaticus monthly newsletter. You can unsubscribe at any time.